Editorial policy and how we source data
This page explains where every number on CoinYearValue comes from, how we check it and what to do if you think one is wrong.
What the three prices mean
- Worn: a coin with normal wear from circulation, roughly Good (G-4) to Very Fine (VF-20) on the 70-point Sheldon scale. This is what most coins from change and old jars are.
- Uncirculated: no wear at all, about MS-60 to MS-63.
- Certified MS65: a near-flawless coin graded and sealed by PCGS or NGC. For copper cents this means full original red color. These prices are for regular strikes, not special designations like Full Bands or Full Steps.
Where values come from
Each value is our own rounded figure, worked out from public sources and never copied from a single guide. Coin year pages give a value for each grade from Good (G4) to MS65, using the PriceCharting, CoinStudy and CoinValueChecker price guides, plus the CopperCoins date guide for Lincoln cents; the next section explains how. Ranges for varieties, errors and paper money are set by comparing public sources: price guides, dealer price lists, and auction and sold-listing records whose prices are visible without a login. When sources disagree, we give more weight to dated, recent figures than to undated lists.
Each variety range carries a confidence level in our records (high, medium or low), based on how closely the sources agreed.
The highest auction price on a year page is the top sale of a regular coin of that year that we could confirm in CoinValueChecker's auction tables, with a link to the Heritage Auctions lot when the sale was at Heritage. Proofs, die varieties and mint errors are not counted in that figure, and sales listed only on eBay are not used.
Value-by-grade tables
Year pages with a value for each grade, from Good (G4) to Gem Uncirculated (MS65), use this method. For every date and mint we read three public sources: the PriceCharting price guide, the CoinStudy price guide (coins through 1964) and the price-by-grade charts on CoinValueChecker. Lincoln cents add a fourth, the CopperCoins date guide, using its brown-coin prices through MS63 and its full-red price for MS65. PriceCharting builds its guide from sold listings, but for grades that rarely sell its figures are model estimates. Each grade is the median of the sources that price it, rounded. Only plain listings count; errors, varieties, proofs and prooflike coins are covered separately. Our records list every source figure behind a value, including the ones left out and why.
- Silver: CoinValueChecker's charts were set at an older, higher silver price, and their lowest prices sit on a flat melt floor. A floor price is not a sale price, so it counts as today's melt only where another source also prices that grade near melt. Worn and MS60 prices above the floor are moved to today's silver price, fully up to 1.5 times the floor and partly up to 2.5 times; higher prices and all MS63 and MS65 prices are used as listed. CoinStudy's near-melt prices are moved to today's silver price too. No silver coin is shown below its melt value.
- Slabbed sales: PriceCharting's graded prices are mostly for coins in grading holders, so they include the grading fee. Below MS65, its prices within $40 of face or melt are left out for MS60 and MS63, and for worn grades of silver coins. On cheap coins, where most sold coins are slabbed, its worn-grade prices are left out entirely. A guide's MS63 price within $40 of face or melt is treated the same way, and MS63 is then filled between MS60 and MS65.
- Common copper, nickel and clad coins: uncirculated coins from rolls sell for far less than single-coin listings. When a coin's MS65 value is under $50, single-coin MS60 and MS63 prices from PriceCharting and CoinValueChecker are left out, and those grades come from the CopperCoins guide or are filled. CoinValueChecker's worn prices for these coins follow a fixed curve rather than sales, so they are used only on a few scarcer dates where the other guide's worn prices sit far below the market. When no source shows a premium, a worn coin is valued at face, or at its copper value for older cents.
- Disagreements: on each source's chart, a price more than 1.5 times the next two higher grades is treated as an error. When only two sources price a grade and PriceCharting's estimate is less than 1/2.5 of the other source's listed price, it is left out. A worn grade that only one PriceCharting grade band prices is filled between the neighboring grades instead, never above that band price. A lower grade priced more than three times the next higher one is left out as bad data.
- Gaps: a grade no source prices is filled between the grades on either side, on a log scale. For common modern coins, where certified gems carry most of the premium, About Uncirculated, MS60 and MS63 sit 8%, 25% and 50% of the way from the worn value to the MS65 price.
- Modern coins: worn zinc cents (1983 on) are valued at face; CopperCoins' 5-cent minimum for worn zinc cents is not a collector premium. For 50 State Quarters (1999–2008), a PriceCharting MS65 more than three times above or below that year's median (the middle of the year's ten state-and-mint MS65 values before this check) is left out, and that median is used when no other source prices that grade.
- Variety pages (such as the 1992 Close AM): values come from each guide's listing for the variety itself, under the same rules. PriceCharting prices below 1/2.5 of the other guides for the same grade are left out first, because its variety listings include ordinary coins sold under the variety's name. Where CopperCoins prints two lines for one coin, their average counts as one source. Worn grades are not valued from CoinValueChecker, whose worn prices are a fixed share of its MS60 price; those pages describe worn coins from recorded sales instead.
- A higher grade is never shown below a lower one.
We keep the source figures behind every value in our records and send any grade backed by a single source for a second check.
Silver and copper prices
For common silver coins, the metal is most of the value. Those prices are calculated in your browser from each coin's silver content and the current silver price from gold-api.com. Silver content uses the Mint's standard weight and fineness for each coin. The melt value calculator shows the math.
Mintages, varieties and history
Mintage figures are U.S. Mint production numbers as published in A Guide Book of United States Coins (the Red Book) and NGC Coin Explorer. For the main silver series (Roosevelt dimes, Washington quarters, Walking Liberty and Franklin halves, Morgan and Peace dollars), each year and mint was compared between the two, and where they disagreed we use the NGC figure. Figures for the other series on our year pages were audited against CollectorsKey, with PCGS CoinFacts or NGC used to settle any difference. Lincoln cents from 1983 on use the U.S. Mint figures compiled in Wikipedia's Lincoln cent mintage table, checked against CopperCoins; the 1999–2008 state quarters use the U.S. Mint production figures published by CoinNews. State quarter proof figures are for each design and come from the proof set totals.
A variety or error is listed only if PCGS, NGC or a standard reference recognizes it, and each one links to its source. Historical facts on year and series pages carry their sources at the end of the section.
How pages are written
We use software tools, including AI writing and research assistants, to gather sources and draft pages. Every value, mintage and historical claim is checked against the sources we record for it before it's published, and pages are edited for plain language. Nothing is copied from another site.
How often values are updated
Silver-based values update live. Fixed ranges are reviewed at least once a year, and sooner if silver moves more than about 25% from the price when they were set. Each value page shows the date its values were last checked.
Corrections
If a value, mintage or fact looks wrong, email [email protected] with the page and, if you can, a source. We check every report and correct confirmed errors on the page.
Independence
No dealer, grading service or marketplace pays for placement or reviews our pages. Ads and affiliate links are kept separate from values. See the affiliate disclosure.
What our values are not
They are not offers to buy or appraisals of your coin. A dealer usually pays less than these ranges, and a scarce coin in exceptional condition can sell for much more. If a coin could bring several hundred dollars, have it authenticated and graded before you sell it.