Minnesota's extra trees, and a Kansas quarter that reads RUST
More collector attention went to the back of the Minnesota quarter than to any other 2005 design. A Kentucky collector reported 91 or 92 coins with an extra evergreen in uncirculated rolls from his local bank, about four per roll, and Numismatic News later tallied doubled-die reverses numbered up to DDR#41 on Philadelphia coins, with separate listings for Denver and the San Francisco proofs. One dealer reported more than 400 of the Philadelphia DDR#1 in a single box of rolls from his stock, so the best-known version is far from scarce. The Denver DDR#1 turned up in a satin-finish mint set. More than 50 doubled reverse dies have been catalogued, and only the strongest bring real money. On some 2005-P coins a die clash pressed lines from Washington's portrait into the reverse in front of the boat, and sellers have advertised the mark as a fish.
Kansas has its own story. On some 2005-P coins, grease mixed with metal dust filled the T in TRUST on Washington's side, so the motto reads IN GOD WE RUST. The bison on the back was chosen by Kansas high school students, who gave it 36% of 48,080 votes, and after complaints that its forward-pointing horns were wrong, the governor said the Mint would redraw them before minting.
Output rose to 3,013,600,000 in 2005, the most since 2002. Denver's 404,000,000 Oregon quarters were the year's largest single run, and Oregon's two mints together made 720,200,000. West Virginia, chosen from more than 1,800 ideas sent in statewide, edged that at 721,600,000 combined. The Mint's 22-coin Uncirculated set was the first with a satin finish, and 1,160,000 were sold at $16.95.
What to check on this one
- Minnesota: use a 5x to 10x loupe on the evergreens. True doubled dies show rounded, separated duplicate branches, while machine doubling looks flat and shelf-like.
- Kansas 2005-P: on Washington's side, find the T in TRUST. It should be faint or gone while the neighboring letters stay sharp. A Denver coin with this problem is not the known error.
- Satin coins from mint sets have a frosted, low-gloss surface. Don't mistake one for a cleaned or worn circulation coin.
Sources: Doubled die state quarter would be first (Numismatic News); More Minnesota quarter doubling found (Numismatic News); Denver state quarter doubling found (Numismatic News); Die clash gives quarter fishy look (Numismatic News); Rare 2005 Quarter Errors Worth Money (CoinValueChecker); Buffalo, with horns retooled, will grace Kansas quarter (Lawrence Journal-World); State quarter coin production figures by U.S. Mint, year and state (CoinNews); The West Virginia Quarter and the New River Gorge Bridge; 2005 Uncirculated Mint Set (Mint Set Guide).




