The 2004-D Wisconsin quarters with a leaf that was never in the design
Denver struck two versions of the Wisconsin quarter that Philadelphia never made. Each has a small extra leaf on the left side of the corn stalk, one curving up toward the top of the ear (the high leaf) and one curving down below it (the low leaf). A normal Wisconsin quarter has no such leaf. Nobody has settled how they got there. One theory is an accidental gouge in the die, another is that someone at the Denver Mint cut them in on purpose, and one price guide argues that two leaf positions on separate dies, found in similar numbers, make pure accident hard to believe. Estimates of how many exist vary widely: the same site gives about 3,000 high leaf and 2,000 low leaf coins on one page and 20,000 to 50,000 of each on another. A Denver press operator told Treasury investigators that 35,000 to 50,000 "leaf up" coins may have been struck and shipped. In February 2005 a set of all three versions sold on eBay for $300, and single coins briefly brought as much as $1,500, a spike that has long since cooled.
Every other 2004 issue is ordinary. Texas from Philadelphia was the biggest run, at 278,800,000, and Iowa from the same mint the smallest, at 213,800,000. Michigan came out on January 26, 2004, the 167th anniversary of its statehood. Iowa's schoolhouse comes from Grant Wood's painting Arbor Day, which shows a Cedar Rapids school as it might have looked in the 1890s, and Florida put a Spanish galleon and a space shuttle on the same coin. The year falls just before the Mint switched its Uncirculated sets to a satin finish in 2005, so 2004 has no satin versions to hunt for. San Francisco struck 2,740,684 clad and 1,769,786 silver proofs of each design.
What to check on this one
- Confirm the D mint mark first. The extra leaf is known only on Denver coins, so treat a Philadelphia coin with a leaf as altered.
- With magnification the leaf should be raised and share the metal flow and texture of the corn husk. A leaf that looks scratched in or recessed was added after striking.
- Note which way the leaf points: up toward the top of the ear is the high leaf, down below it is the low leaf. The high leaf brings more.
- Certified coins sell for more than ungraded ones, so have a find attributed by a grading service before you sell it.
Sources: Mint explains Wisconsin quarter error (Numismatic News); 2004 Wisconsin state quarter misprint (Wikipedia); Rare 2004 Quarter Errors Worth Money (CoinValueChecker); 2004 Quarter Value (CoinValueChecker); State quarter coin production figures by U.S. Mint, year and state (CoinNews); Michigan State Quarter (U.S. Mint); The Story Behind Your State's Quarter (24/7 Wall St.); 2005 Uncirculated Mint Set (Mint Set Guide).




