2006: the year the cent began costing more than a cent, and the melting ban that followed
Through fiscal 2005 the Mint could still make a cent for less than one cent. In 2006 that flipped. A letter from Deputy Director David Lebryk, reported by Numismatic News, put the cost at about 1.4 cents at metal prices then current and projected 1.23 cents for the fiscal year, a shortfall near $20 million on cents. Treasury papers say costs have stayed above face value every year since fiscal 2006.
With the metal worth more than the coin, the Mint acted on December 14, 2006. An interim rule banned melting one-cent and five-cent coins and restricted exports. Travelers could take out $5, and individuals could ship $100 at a time. Knowing violations carried a fine of up to $10,000, up to five years in prison, or both, and coins melted or exported illegally were forfeited.
Collectors know 2006 for doubled dies. CopperCoins catalogs 28 doubled die obverses, all Philadelphia, plus 48 doubled reverses across three mints. Most are minor. One of them, 1DO-008, shows notching on the ERTY of LIBERTY and a thicker left arm on the Y, and it is listed at roughly $2 in F12 and $15 in gem condition. The variety on this page is a separate die with its doubling on the ear, and the premium belongs to that die, not to the year.
With so many dies on the books, a 2006 cent that looks doubled is easy to find and usually a letdown. Only strong, specific doubling is worth sending for attribution.
What to check on this one
- Look at Lincoln's ear first. A true doubled die shows a second, separated outline of the lobe. A smeared or flattened look is machine doubling.
- Check the Y in LIBERTY. Several catalogued 2006 dies show a thickened Y arm or notched ERTY, which sells for a few dollars, nowhere near the ear die.
- Check the back as well. Reverse doubling was catalogued on all three mints that year, including Denver and the San Francisco proofs.
Sources: Numismatic News: Nickel, cent exceed face; United States Mint: Mint moves to limit exportation, melting of coins (Dec 14, 2006); Treasury: FY2013 U.S. Mint Congressional Justification; CopperCoins: 2006 Lincoln Cent Date Guide; CopperCoins: 2006-P 1DO-008.

