Three low-mintage 1931 dimes, still sold at face value by the Mint in 1934
Dime production kept falling in 1931: Philadelphia struck 3,150,000, San Francisco 1,800,000 and Denver 1,260,000, and the next two years brought none at all. All three are semi-key dates, yet they are not truly rare, because many were saved, and banks still had 1931 dimes on hand once the economy recovered. As late as June 1934, collectors could buy uncirculated 1931 dimes from the Mint at face value plus postage.
Most 1931-D dimes were not even released in 1931. They sat in bags because commerce did not need them, and when they finally came out, speculators bought uncirculated rolls on the strength of the low mintage. That history makes the 1931-D the most common of the three with Full Bands, though gems are still genuinely scarce. The record is $5,880 for an MS67 FB.
The 1931-S is the scarcest of the three with Full Bands, since San Francisco strikes often lack the sharp detail of Denver or Philadelphia coins. The first MS67+ FB was not certified until 2019, and in June that year it brought $270,250, the highest price for any 1931 dime.
Philadelphia's coins took hard use during the Depression, and solid circulated survivors are harder to find than the mintage suggests; an MS67+ FB has reached $17,400. Both branch mints have a doubled die obverse. The 1931-D FS-101 shows doubling on IN GOD WE TRUST and is subtle enough that many have gone unattributed; an MS67+ holds the record at $2,640.
What to check on this one
- Check IN GOD WE TRUST under magnification on any 1931-D or 1931-S; the doubled dies of this year are subtle and often missed.
- On a 1931-S in Mint State, the bands are the whole story; Full Bands examples are far scarcer than for the other two mints.
- Uncirculated rolls were saved, so Mint State 1931 dimes do turn up; make sure the luster is original and the surfaces uncleaned before paying a Mint State price.
Sources: Mercury dime (Wikipedia); 1931 Mercury dime value (CoinValueChecker).

