Certified MS65$300Near flawless, graded by PCGS or NGC
A worn 1931 nickel sells for about $9–18.
Uncirculated ones bring $86–145, and a certified MS65 brings $300.
It's worth more than face value even when worn. Compare it with the table, and check the mint mark before selling.
Advertisement
Only San Francisco made 1931 nickels, and people saved them at once
Every 1931 Buffalo nickel came from San Francisco. The Depression had left little need for new coins, and among non-gold coins only cents, nickels and dimes were struck that year. San Francisco made 194,000 nickels in January and stopped. Acting Mint Director Mary Margaret O'Reilly then asked it to strike more so the tiny issue would not just be hoarded, and the mint found enough metal, partly by melting worn-out nickels, to bring the total to about 1.2 million, most of it struck in a rush during November and December.
Her plan did not stop the saving. Dealers and speculators, among them Wayte Raymond, put away original rolls because the mintage was obviously small and they expected the coins to gain value, and lower Mint State examples are fairly easy to buy today. There may even be more uncirculated 1931-S nickels than circulated ones, and a worn piece with a fully readable date can be the harder find.
That leaves the 1931-S as the second-lowest mintage of the series, behind only the 1926-S, but far easier to own. The 1926-S slipped into circulation with little notice, while the 1931-S was set aside from the day it appeared. It becomes a true condition rarity only above MS66, where dies worn out during the hurried late-year production show their effects on the details of many coins.
What to check on this one
Every genuine 1931 Buffalo nickel has an S below FIVE CENTS; a 1931 without one has an altered date or a removed mint mark.
Do not assume a worn 1931-S is the cheap version: because so many were hoarded uncirculated, circulated coins with a full, sharp date are not common.
What each 1931 nickel is worth, by grade and mint mark
Grade
S
GoodGoodG4Heavily worn; date and letters still readable
$9
FineFineF12Worn, but all the main lettering is clear
$12
Very FineV. FineVF20Light to moderate wear on the high spots
$18
Extremely FineEx. FineEF40Light wear on the highest spots only
$27
About UncirculatedAbout Unc.AU50Traces of wear, some original shine
$48
UncirculatedUnc.MS60No wear, but plenty of marks
$86
Choice UncirculatedChoice Unc.MS63No wear and only a few marks
$145
Gem UncirculatedGem Unc.MS65Certified and nearly flawless
$300
Good through About Uncirculated are for coins as found, not in a grading holder. MS60 and MS63 are uncirculated coins; MS65 is a coin certified by PCGS or NGC. Values checked November 15, 2026 against public price guides and auction records. How values work.
What a 1931 nickel looks like
FrontBack
Shown: a 1913 Buffalo nickel (front from a Type 1 coin, back from a Type 2 coin), the same design used through 1938. Photos: National Numismatic Collection, National Museum of American History (photo by Jaclyn Nash), Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons (front, back).
Varieties and errors to check
No major varieties are listed for 1931 nickels. Minor errors and die varieties interest specialists, but for ordinary coins condition and mint mark set the value.
Find the mint mark
Back of the coin, below the words FIVE CENTS, under the bison. Philadelphia coins have no letter.
What it's made of
75% copper, 25% nickel, 5.0 grams
Melting cents and nickels is not allowed under U.S. Mint rules, so copper and nickel value is a guide only.
Mintage
How many were made
Coin
Type
Mintage
1931-S
For circulation
1,200,000
Questions
Is a 1931 nickel silver?
No. 1931 nickels are made of 75% copper, 25% nickel.
Which 1931 nickel is worth the most?
All 1931 nickels made for circulation are valued alike: about $300 in MS65.
Where is the mint mark on a 1931 nickel?
Back of the coin, below the words FIVE CENTS, under the bison. Philadelphia coins have no letter.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. As an eBay Partner Network affiliate, we may also earn a commission when you buy through links on this site, at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure.