The biggest Buffalo nickel run, and the year proof nickels came back
No Buffalo nickel issue was made in larger numbers than the 1936 Philadelphia coin, at nearly 119 million pieces. Denver added 24,814,000 and San Francisco 14,930,000, and the Denver coins usually came out fairly sharp. With that many made, worn examples of all three mints are some of the easiest Buffalo nickels to find. Philadelphia coins of this year usually show strong strikes, though top gems are harder to come by, and the Philadelphia record is $18,000 for an MS68 sold at Heritage in 2025.
It is also the year proofs returned. The Mint had stopped selling proof coins about 20 years earlier, and it restarted with a satin finish that resembled the old matte proofs. Buyers did not care for it, so partway through the year the Mint switched to the mirror-like brilliant finish. The two kinds together came to just 4,420 coins. A brilliant proof graded PR68 sold for $40,250 at Heritage in March 2007, the highest price yet paid for any 1936 nickel. Among coins made for circulation, a 1936-D graded MS68 is close behind at $37,375.
Denver produced the year's variety. One reverse die was polished so heavily that the middle of the bison's right foreleg faded away, and the coins it struck are known as the 1936-D 3½ legs. It is a different and much less famous coin than the 1937-D three-legged nickel, though it is faked the same way, by grinding part of a leg off an ordinary 1936-D.
What to check on this one
- On a 1936-D, check the bison's right foreleg with a 10x loupe: a weak or missing middle section on a sharp coin suggests the 3½ legs variety, while scratches or a scooped surface there mean someone removed it.
- A 1936 nickel with no mint mark and mirror-like fields may be a brilliant proof, and one with a soft, even satin glow could be a satin proof; both are worth having checked.
Sources: 1936 nickel value (CoinValueChecker); Buffalo nickel (Wikipedia).

