Three top prices from one January sale
The top prices CoinValueChecker lists for all three 1938 business strikes came from one Heritage sale on January 19, 2025. A 1938-S graded MS68 red brought $14,400, the highest price for any 1938 business-strike cent. A PCGS MS68 red Philadelphia coin sold for $9,000, and a 1938-D in MS68 red reached $7,200.
Those prices sit at the very top of a common date. Philadelphia struck 156,682,000, Denver 20,010,000 and San Francisco 15,180,000, the scarcest of the year. Worn coins of all three sell for pocket change, under a quarter in Good on this page. Only 7 Denver coins have reached MS68 red across PCGS and NGC combined, and San Francisco coins consistently bring the most in high grades.
Color does most of the work in between. Red means 95% or more of the original copper color, red-brown 5% to 94%, and brown means most of it has oxidized. At the top grades, a brown coin brings only a fraction of the price of a red one.
Variety collectors look for repunched mint marks: an S/S (FS-501) and a triple-punched S/S/S (FS-502) from San Francisco, and a D/D (FS-501) from Denver. Philadelphia sold 14,734 proofs directly to collectors, only the third year of proofs after a 20-year gap, in simple cellophane sleeves, and 1938 was also the year the Jefferson nickel replaced the Buffalo nickel.
What to check on this one
- Look at the S on a 1938-S under a loupe for extra outlines of the letter. Two or three overlapping S shapes mean a repunched mint mark worth more than a plain coin.
- Check the D on a 1938-D the same way; the D/D repunch is listed as FS-501.
- If a 1938 with no mint mark has mirror-like fields, compare it with images of the 1938 proofs, which were struck more than once with polished dies, before selling it as a business strike.
Sources: 1938 Wheat Penny Value (CoinValueChecker); 1938 Lincoln Cent Date Guide (CopperCoins).

