A Philadelphia Full Bands record, strong San Francisco strikes, and a doubled 1940-S
Philadelphia struck 65,350,000 dimes in 1940, and that heavy production wore dies hard, so sharply struck Full Bands coins are scarce compared with the output. As a result, the highest-mintage coin of the year holds the record: a PCGS MS68+ FB sold for $35,250 at Legend Rare Coin Auctions in March 2019, while MS68 coins without Full Bands have sold for as little as $800. Circulated pieces trade near melt.
San Francisco's 21,560,000 dimes back up its reputation for quality strikes. The Full Bands record is $9,775 for an MS68 at Heritage in August 2000, but a non-FB MS68+ brought $8,519 at Legend in April 2023, nearly matching it, a sign of how much buyers trust S-mint strikes. Below MS67 the 1940-S is affordable and easy to find.
Denver made 21,198,000. Its strikes are consistent through MS65, but the certified population thins out hard above that, and an MS68 holds the record at $3,565 at Heritage in July 2003.
The 1940-S has an unusual variety, FS-901, with doubling on both sides: LIBERTY and IN GOD WE TRUST on the front, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA and E PLURIBUS UNUM on the back. Dies of the period needed two impressions from a hub to bring up the full design, and a slight shift between them left the doubling. A repunched S, FS-501, also exists. Philadelphia struck 11,827 proofs, most now PR64 to PR67, and a PR69 sold for $15,295 at Heritage in 2005.
What to check on this one
- On a 1940-S, check LIBERTY and E PLURIBUS UNUM for a spread or shadow on the letter edges; doubling on both sides points to the FS-901.
- For the FS-501 repunched S, look at the upper and lower curves of the S under magnification; wear can hide the second punch.
- Don't overlook a sharp 1940 Philadelphia dime; Full Bands coins from that mint are scarcer than its mintage suggests.
Sources: 1940 Mercury dime value (CoinValueChecker); Mercury dime (Wikipedia).

