The 1916 doubled die date, and the year the design was retouched
The Mint made small changes to the Buffalo nickel in 1916. LIBERTY was given more emphasis and moved slightly, and Walter Breen wrote that engraver Charles Barber lengthened the Indian's nose a little, though Q. David Bowers questions whether the portrait changed at all. In Breen's view none of it helped, and the coins were still rarely well struck.
The year's great rarity is the 1916 doubled die obverse, FS-101, struck at Philadelphia. The date shows a bold second outline, clearest on the final 1 and 6, and the lips and chin are doubled too, often plainly enough to see without a glass. Somewhere between 200 and 500 survive, mostly in mid-range circulated grades, with fewer than two dozen uncirculated. An MS64, the top grade for the variety, reached $281,750 at Bowers and Merena in 2004.
Denver struck 13,333,000, roughly a fifth of Philadelphia's total, and the 1916-D is scarce in circulated grades and hard to find at MS65 or better; most survivors have solid strikes and satiny luster. San Francisco's 11,860,000 was the smallest mintage of the three. Worn 1916-S nickels are easier to find than some other early San Francisco dates, but at MS65 and above the 1916-S is rarer than the 1913-S Type 2, the 1914-S and the 1915-S.
Philadelphia's 63,498,066 coins are the common ones, and they are the only 1916 nickels that can carry the doubled date.
What to check on this one
- To check for the doubled die, start with the final 1 and 6 under a 10x glass, look for second shapes below and to the right of the digits, then confirm matching doubling on the lips and chin.
- Mechanical doubling and die wear are far more common than the real doubled die and worth very little; several matching doubled features are a better sign than one thick number.
- If a 1916 passes those checks, have it authenticated right away.
Sources: Buffalo nickel (Wikipedia); 1916 nickel value (CoinValueChecker).

