A scarce 1917-S, a well-struck Philadelphia coin, and several die varieties
With only 4,193,000 made, the 1917-S is the scarcest regular nickel of the year. Many were weakly struck, though some came out with solid detail and attractive frosty luster. An MS67, at the time the finest certified by either major grading service, sold for $138,000 at Heritage in 2008.
The 1917-D, with a mintage just under 10 million, is scarcer than the Philadelphia coin from the start. Strikes vary, so a full horn and a clean bison's back are what separate a nice coin from a premium one. At the top of the census, an MS67* brought $20,700.
Philadelphia struck 51,424,029, yet in gem condition the 1917 is about as rare as the 1914 and rarer than the 1915, 1916 and 1919. It tends to be the best struck of the three 1917 issues, which gives it an edge in the upper Mint State grades.
Varieties make 1917 a strong year as well. Philadelphia has two doubled die reverses, FS-801 and FS-802; the second shows most clearly in E PLURIBUS UNUM, and an FS-801 in MS64 sold for $11,500 at Bowers and Merena on June 17, 2010. Two Feathers coins (FS-401) came from all three mints, the S-mint version scarcest. Denver also has a Three and a Half Legs die (FS-901), with a front leg partly ground away in the same kind of die polishing that later produced the better-known 1937-D three-legged nickel; an MS63 brought $2,640 at Heritage in August 2019. A 1917 date with no trace of an 8 is a regular 1917, not the 1918/7-D overdate.
What to check on this one
- On a 1917 Philadelphia coin, compare E PLURIBUS UNUM with a normal 1917 under a 10x glass and light from more than one side; that is the first place to look for doubling.
- On a Two Feathers coin, the space between the long top feather and the braid should be completely smooth.
- On a 1917-D with a weak front leg, the leg should fade partway down the shaft; a coin that is simply worn unevenly is not the FS-901 variety.
Sources: 1917 nickel value (CoinValueChecker); Buffalo nickel (Wikipedia).

