Rare nickels worth money
Buffalo and Jefferson nickels worth far more than five cents: the doubled dies, overdates and repunched mint marks to look for.
1916 doubled die obverse Buffalo nickel (FS-101)
Typical value: $5,000–25,000 (Good to About Uncirculated)
Look for: A clearly doubled date: the 1916 shows a second, offset set of numerals, plain without a magnifier on most survivors. Philadelphia only, so there is no mint mark under FIVE CENTS.
The working die took two misaligned impressions from the hub. Almost all known examples are worn, and it is the most valuable Buffalo nickel doubled die.
Sources: CoinValueChecker, PriceCharting, US Coins Guide
1918/7-D overdate Buffalo nickel (FS-101)
Typical value: $1,100–8,500 (Very Good to Extremely Fine)
Look for: Look at the last digit of the date on the front: part of a 7 shows under the 8, clearest on coins with little wear. Genuine pieces have a D mint mark below FIVE CENTS on the back. Altered dates are common, so certification matters.
The Denver working die was impressed with both a 1917-dated hub and a 1918-dated hub, leaving a 7 under the 8. It is rare in every grade.
Sources: CoinValueChecker, PriceCharting, US Coins Guide
1937-D three-legged Buffalo nickel (FS-901)
Typical value: $500–5,800 (Very Good to MS63)
Look for: On the back, the bison's front right leg is missing; only the hoof remains. Genuine coins also show raised dots or an arc-shaped mark under the belly (die rust) and a rough, pitted rear leg, and the D mint mark sits below FIVE CENTS. Fakes made by grinding the leg off a normal 1937-D show tool or file marks where the leg should be, so buy certified.
A Denver press operator polished a clashed reverse die to remove the clash marks and ground away the bison's front leg. Every known example comes from that one die.
Sources: CoinValueChecker, PriceCharting, US Coins Guide
1942-D, D over horizontal D nickel (FS-501)
Typical value: $50–3,100 (Very Good to MS63)
Look for: Look at the D mint mark to the right of Monticello on the back (this is a regular copper-nickel 1942-D, not a wartime silver nickel). The outline of a D punched sideways shows under the upright D; on most examples it can be seen without magnification.
A Denver die was first punched with a D lying on its side, then corrected with an upright D, and the sideways D stayed visible.
Sources: CoinValueChecker, PriceCharting, US Coins Guide
1936-D 3½ legs Buffalo nickel (FS-901)
Typical value: $450–2,000 (Good to Very Fine)
Look for: Confirm the 1936 date and the D below FIVE CENTS, then look at the bison's right foreleg with a 10x loupe: the middle of the leg is partly missing or much weaker than on a normal coin. Fakers grind the leg off ordinary 1936-D nickels, so scratches or a scooped surface there are a warning; buy certified.
A Denver reverse die was polished so heavily that part of the recessed leg detail was removed. It is a different, rarer variety from the 1937-D three-legged nickel, and 1937 prices do not apply to it.
Sources: CoinValueChecker, PriceCharting
1935 doubled die reverse Buffalo nickel (FS-801)
Typical value: $60–900 (Very Good to Extremely Fine)
Look for: On the back, FIVE CENTS shows strong doubling, and E PLURIBUS UNUM shows lighter doubling; a 5x loupe makes the letter outlines plain. Philadelphia coins only (no mint mark under FIVE CENTS).
The hub shifted between impressions while the reverse die was made. It is the best-known doubled die reverse in the Buffalo series, and most known examples are well worn.
Sources: CoinValueChecker, PriceCharting, US Coins Guide
1939 doubled MONTICELLO nickel (FS-801)
Typical value: $25–780 (Very Good to MS63)
Look for: On the back, MONTICELLO and FIVE CENTS are strongly doubled; the extra letter outlines show under a 5x loupe and on strong coins without one. Philadelphia coins only (no mint mark to the right of Monticello).
A doubled die reverse made when the hub and die were misaligned. It is one of the three major doubled dies in the Jefferson series.
Sources: CoinValueChecker, PriceCharting, US Coins Guide
1914/(3) date variety Buffalo nickel (FS-101)
Typical value: $350–600 (Good to Extremely Fine)
Look for: Look at the top of the final 4 in the date with a loupe. A strong example shows a rounded, bulbous curve there, the trace of an earlier digit, possibly a 3; some coins also show faint extra outlines on the other digits. Weak examples need careful magnification. Philadelphia only, so there is no mint mark under FIVE CENTS.
One proposed explanation is the reuse of an earlier dated master die. Specialists still debate whether it is a true overdate, which is why the 3 is written in parentheses, and three or possibly four working dies have been identified.
Sources: CoinValueChecker, PriceCharting
1917-D 3½ legs Buffalo nickel (FS-901)
Typical value: $160–550 (Good to Very Fine)
Look for: A D below FIVE CENTS and a front leg on the bison that looks faded or incomplete partway down the shaft, rather than cleanly missing. Uneven wear can look similar, so compare the leg with an attributed example under a 10x loupe.
Part of the leg was ground away when a Denver reverse die was polished. It is found only on Denver coins.
Sources: CoinValueChecker, PriceCharting
1943/2-P overdate nickel (FS-101)
Typical value: $35–490 (Very Good to MS63)
Look for: Use a 10x loupe on the 3 in the date: part of a 2 shows at the bottom of the 3, inside its lower curve. This is a 35% silver wartime nickel with a large P above Monticello's dome on the back. Light doubling also shows on IN GOD WE TRUST and LIBERTY.
The working die was impressed first with a 1942 hub and then a 1943 hub, so it is both an overdate and a doubled die.
Sources: CoinValueChecker, PriceCharting, US Coins Guide
1949-D/S overmintmark nickel (FS-501)
Typical value: $20–410 (Very Good to MS65)
Look for: Look at the D to the right of Monticello on the back with a 10x loupe: curved bits of an S poke out from under the D, most visible at the top.
A die first punched with an S for San Francisco was repunched with a D and used at Denver.
Sources: CoinValueChecker, US Coins Guide
1943-P doubled eye nickel (FS-106)
Typical value: $15–330 (Very Good to MS65)
Look for: Look at Jefferson's eye: a second outline makes it look like two overlapping eyes. A 5x loupe also shows doubling on LIBERTY, the date and IN GOD WE TRUST. Large P mint mark above Monticello's dome on the back.
A doubled die obverse from a hub and die that were out of alignment. It is the best-known obverse doubled die in the Jefferson series.
Sources: CoinValueChecker, PriceCharting, US Coins Guide
1938-D/S overmintmark Buffalo nickel
Typical value: $15–190 (Very Good to certified MS65)
Look for: On the back below FIVE CENTS, the D mint mark sits on top of an S: curves of the S stick out above and below the D. Only strong examples carry the full premium; weak ones trade near a normal 1938-D.
Dies prepared for San Francisco were not needed when Buffalo nickel production there stopped, so the Mint punched a D over the S and sent them to Denver.
Sources: CoinValueChecker, PriceCharting, US Coins Guide
Each range runs between the grades shown next to it, from a worn coin to an uncirculated or proof one. Coins in top condition can sell for far more. Values were checked in November 2026 against the sources listed with each coin. Anything here worth more than a few hundred dollars should be checked by a grading service.
Every date and mintage: Buffalo nickels, Jefferson nickels. More lists: rare pennies, quarters, dimes, half dollars, dollar coins.