CoinYearValue

Rare nickels worth money

Buffalo and Jefferson nickels worth far more than five cents: the doubled dies, overdates and repunched mint marks to look for.

Each range runs between the grades shown next to it, from a worn coin to an uncirculated or proof one. Coins in top condition can sell for far more. Values were checked in November 2026 against the sources listed with each coin. Anything here worth more than a few hundred dollars should be checked by a grading service.

Every date and mintage: Buffalo nickels, Jefferson nickels. More lists: rare pennies, quarters, dimes, half dollars, dollar coins.